As someone who’s lived in Port Jefferson for years, I’ve had plenty of time to discover the spots that make this town special. Whether you’re new to the area or just popping in for a visit, I’m excited to share some of my favorite places with you. These are the spots where I love to spend my weekends, grab a bite, or just take in the beautiful views with my family.
Here’s a quick list of the places I’ll be talking about:
- Kilwins – Ice cream and chocolate heaven
- The Frigate Candy Store – A must for candy lovers
- Pasta Pasta – Best garlic bread in town
- Tiger Lily Café – Great lunch spot
- Earring Taboo – Fun and funky jewelry shop
- Barrito – Delicious Mexican food and cocktails
- The Marina – Perfect for a coffee stroll
- Water park with turtles – Family-friendly fun for the kids
- Long Island Explorium – A small, interactive science museum for families
Before I share why I love these spots, let’s quickly dive into the history of downtown Port Jefferson, NY!
A Brief History of Downtown Port Jefferson
Downtown Port Jefferson, originally known as Drowned Meadow, has a rich history dating back to the 1600s when it was first settled by early colonialists. It was initially a quiet farming and fishing village, but the area began to thrive in the 19th century with the rise of shipbuilding.
By the 1830s, Port Jefferson had transformed into a significant shipbuilding hub, constructing massive wooden ships that contributed to the booming maritime industry of the time. The town became known for its skilled shipbuilders and shipyards, which attracted workers and craftsmen from all over, leading to the growth of the local economy.
By the early 20th century, as the shipbuilding industry declined, Port Jefferson shifted its focus toward becoming a recreational and tourist destination, which it still embraces today. Its picturesque marina, charming downtown streets, and historical landmarks draw visitors year-round. The town has preserved much of its historical architecture, which adds to its charm, blending the past with a vibrant present full of shops, restaurants, and cultural spots that reflect both its seafaring roots and modern development.
Today, Port Jefferson’s downtown is a blend of historic landmarks and modern-day attractions. Visitors can explore the Bayles Shipyard, learn about maritime history at the Port Jefferson Village Center, and enjoy annual events like the Dickens Festival, which brings history to life in the streets. With its scenic harbor views and strong ties to its shipbuilding past, Port Jefferson remains a town steeped in history while welcoming people from all walks of life.
Start with Something Sweet
First things first, let’s talk ice cream. Kilwins is a must-stop if you’re craving something sweet. They’re known for their handmade fudge and, of course, their ice cream. I love that the second you walk in, you can smell the waffle cones being made—it’s seriously heaven! Whether you go for a classic flavor like chocolate or something more adventurous, you can’t go wrong. Grab a cone and take a stroll down Main Street, it’s the perfect way to kick off your day.
The Frigate Candy Store is another spot my kids and I adore. They’ve got everything from old-school candy to delicious ice cream, so if you’ve got a sweet tooth, you’re in the right place. The kids love picking out treats, and honestly, I do too!
Favorite Food Spots
When it’s time to eat, you’ve got to check out Pasta Pasta. This place has the best garlic bread in town, and their pasta dishes are always on point. It’s one of those spots where you can have a great family dinner or just a cozy meal with friends.
If you’re looking for a fun lunch spot, Tiger Lily Café is perfect. It’s a local favorite for fresh, healthy food, and it’s got this great vibe—super laid-back and perfect for a midday break.
For something with a bit more kick, head over to Barrito. They do amazing Mexican food, and the bar there is a great place to relax with a margarita after a long day. It’s a lively spot and one of my personal favorites when I want something fun and flavorful.
Unique Shopping and Fun
Now, if you’re into unique finds, Tabu is a fun place to pop into. I used to go there all the time with friends before I had kids, and it’s still just as fun now. They’ve got all sorts of funky jewelry—whether you’re looking for something playful or just want to browse, it’s a great spot.
For Families
If you’re with kids, don’t miss the little water park with turtles that squirt water! It’s so cute, and the perfect way to let the kids burn off some energy on a warm day. Plus, there’s also the Long Island Explorium, a small but super fun science museum. It’s hands-on and educational, so it’s a win-win for the whole family.
Enjoy the View
Finally, grab a coffee—whether you’re a Starbucks fan or prefer a local café—and take a walk down to the marina. There’s something so peaceful about watching the boats come and go, especially when the sun starts to set. It’s one of my favorite ways to wind down and soak in the beauty of Port Jeff.
